MODULE 7: Partnering with Local Communities

Importance of partners(1)

Q: “Which single intervention would do the most to improve the health of those living on less that $1 per day?”
A: “Hire community health workers to serve them.” – Dr. Paul Farmer(2)

Research on global health NGO effectiveness leaves little doubt as to the importance of working with local partners:

“The balance of evidence from published literature and case study accounts is clear… The greater the level of local community involvement in setting agendas for action and in the practice of health promotion, the larger the impact.”(3)

“Health programs should involve community members at all levels of assessment, design, implementation, and evaluation.”(4)

“To increase quality of interventions, communities must become partners of the health system.”(5)

Involving local community leaders, volunteers, health workers, and clinics is essential to effect sustainable improvements in healthcare for many reasons. The following six aims of global healthcare programs outline the many roles of local workers, and illustrate why partnerships are so vitally important.

Confidence: When patients are skeptical of visiting doctors, local leaders are trustworthy, and can inspire confidence in the mission of the global health organization. Alternatively, if global health organizations fail to work with local medical personnel, they may undermine the community’s confidence in their local health system, which will further diminish community health.

Continuity: Without the dedication of local on-the-ground partners, healthcare improvements implemented by global health organizations can only be temporary at best. Follow-up, ongoing, and preventive care all depend on the presence of local medical providers. Local partners are permanently in-country, and only they can link patients with year-round medical care.

Comprehensiveness: Local leaders and local health professionals are best-equipped to assess community needs. While visiting physicians can observe patients’ symptoms and superficially assess the current status of community health, local doctors are familiar with the underlying roots of health problems, as well as with patterns of disease and treatment. On-the-ground collaborators are similarly familiar with which communities are most needy, and can act as case-finders. Without the insights of locals, it would be nearly impossible to get the right healthcare to the all the right people.

Coordination: Global health organizations often face enormous logistical challenges when entering communities with poor infrastructural systems. A local staff can facilitate everything from transportation and lodging to assessing medical needs to publicizing healthcare programs in needy communities.

Cultural Sensitivity:

“From the local world of the community clinic or oncology unit to the transnational workings of human rights agencies, attentiveness to the concept of culture can illuminate how patients, family members, and health care providers interpret illness, healing, and moral obligations.”(6)

Local health workers are themselves part of the target community. They understand local cultural norms and can usually relate better to patients, improving healthcare delivery. As the interface between the community and the healthcare system, local partners are vital to ensuring effective communication and cultural sensitivity.

Capacity:(7) Healthcare delivery systems must be maintained and continually improved. Without community collaborators, health improvements implemented by global health organizations are only transient. Healthcare workers are essential to healthcare delivery, and are thus part of the healthcare infrastructure. In order to achieve the ultimate goal of a permanent, effective medical system, global health organizations rely on capable local medical providers, community workers, leaders, and organizations. Only after building local capacity can a healthcare system be self-sustaining.

What is the role of the nonprofit/NGO’s role in the partnership relationship?(9)

Who ultimately has authority?

Local doctors should be in charge of local programs. When it comes to assessing who needs what resources, community leaders and medical providers know best. Global health organizations are to provide support and direction, but cannot hold sustained decision-making power. Top-down approaches to global health development place the power in the hands of government or large organizations have proven inefficient, ineffective, and susceptible to corruption, and thus NGOs and non-profits must implement a bottom-up, grassroots approach.(10) By working with local partners from the bottom-up, global health organizations encourage communities to invest in and take ownership of their healthcare systems, which ultimately leads to sustained improvements. Dr. James Clarke, an ophthalmologist in Ghana who partners with Unite For Sight, explains how working through communities instead of through governments has facilitated healthcare expansion:

“We really need to encourage a lot of NGOs who are interested in eye care to follow Unite For Sight’s example, namely to work from the bottom up. You know, when NGOs come into a country and they approach the government, the authorities, they don’t come and do eye care. When it starts, there are a lot of costs – the overhead, the running of the program – so very little actually goes to those who should benefit from the program. But in the case of Unite For Sight, they came, they got in touch with us – a very small clinic – and when we started outreaches to communities, people started benefitting… Initially when it started we would write letters to districts, to churches, to communities asking if we could do outreach. When we started and people started seeing the results, they were calling us and writing to us and inviting us. We don’t have to make any contacts again. There are so many people that are waiting for us.”(11) -- Dr. James Clarke, Crystal Eye Clinic, Unite For Sight Partner in Ghana

Go To Module 8: Ethical, Quality Volunteering >>

Footnotes

(1) Bhanari, A., Dratler, S., Raube, K and Thulasiraj, R.D. “Specialty Care Systems: A Pioneering Vision for Global Health.” Health Affairs. 27.4 (2008): 964-976. Accessed on 08 October 2008. <http://content.healthaffairs.org/cgi/content/full/27/4/964>

(2) Yamey, G. “Which single intervention would do the most to improve the health of those living on less than $1 per day?” PLoS Medicine. 4.10 (October 2007): 1557-1560. Accessed on 13 October 2008.  <http://medicine.plosjournals.org/archive/1549-1676/4/10/pdf/10.1371_journal.pmed.0040303-S.pdf>

(3) Gillies, P. “Effectiveness of alliances and partnerships for health promotion.” Health Promotion International. 13.2 (1998): 99-120. Accessed on 08 October 2008. <http://www.uofaweb.ualberta.ca/ahln/pdfs/Effectiveness_of_alliances_andPartnerships_for_Health_Promotion.pdf>

(4) “The Partners in Health Model of Care.” Partners in Health. PIH.org Accessed on 09 October 2008. <http://pih.org/what/PIHmodel.html>

(5) Leban, K. and Walker, L. “NGOs in Global Health: How Do They Matter?” 20 October 2006. CORE Group presentation at USAID Global Health Mini-University, George Washington University. MAQweb.org. Accessed on 08 October 2008. <www.maqweb.org/miniu/present/2006/NGOs.ppt>

(6) Turner, L. “From the Local to the Global: Bioethics and the Concept of Culture.” Journal of Medicine and Philosophy. 30 (June 2005): 305-320.

(7) Labonte, R. and Laverack, G. “Capacity building in health promotion, Part 1: for whom? And for what purpose?” Critical Public Health. 11.2 (2001): 111-127. Accessed on 13 October 2008. <http://web.ebscohost.com/ehost/pdf?vid=2&hid=4&sid=245a5c76-715d-4136-be61-6a261be44a20%40sessionmgr9>

(8) “Partners in Health: A Model for Delivering health and Social Justice for the Poor.” Model.pih.org. Accessed on 13 October 2008. <http://model.pih.org/model>

(9) “Community Health Workers: Recruitment, Payment, Supervision.” Partners in Health Model Online. Model.pih.org. Accessed on 08 October 2008. <http://model.pih.org/community_health_workers>

(10) See, for example, Macfarlane, S., Racelis, M. and Muli-Muslime, F. “Public health in developing countries.” The Lancet. 356.9232 (September 2000): 787-788. Accessed on 13 October 2008. <http://www.sciencedirect.com/science?_ob=ArticleURL&_udi=B6T1B-43P3TK1-N&_user=483692&_rdoc=1&_fmt=&_orig=search&_sort=d&view=c&_version=1&_urlVersion=0&_userid=483692&md5=14378cda622e703dc75afeb6030c5985#bib54>

(11) “Dr. Clarke Speaks about Volunteers and Unite For Sight’s Importance in Ghana.” Online video clip. Uniteforsight.org. Accessed on 08 October 2008. <http://www.uniteforsight.org/intl_volunteer/drclarkevolunteering.php>

Global Health Course